Home Land War The Generals Some Prominent British Generals and their Fortunes in The Great War - Smith-Dorrien

Some Prominent British Generals and their Fortunes in The Great War - Smith-Dorrien

Article Index
Some Prominent British Generals and their Fortunes in The Great War
Allenby
Birdwood
Byng
French
Gough
Haig
Horne
Kitchener
Plumer
Rawlinson
Robertson
Smith-Dorrien
Wilson
All Pages

SMITH-DORRIEN, (S D) Horace Lockward (1858-1930)

smith-dorrien-general-sir-horaceSmith-Dorrien was a classic example of a promising military career cut short by the personal and professional animosity of a superior officer; in this case Field Marshal John Denton Pinkstone French (idem.).

Smith-Dorrien joined the BEF on 20 August 1914 as commander of II Corps after the sudden death from a heart attack on 17 August 1914 of its commander General James Grierson. Faced with most of the force of the German onslaught at Mons, Smith-Dorrien more than coped until ordered to retreat by French. He then made, on his own initiative, a vital stand at Le Cateau on 28 August 1914 that was critical in saving the cohesion of the BEF. Initially, this stand was fulsomely praised by French, although he deliberately withdrew his own I Corps leaving Smith-Dorrien’s II Corps unsupported. Smith-Dorrien was threatened with dismissal by French for disobeying orders at Le Cateau, but was saved by the intervention by Haig (idem.).

As commander of II Corps, Smith-Dorrien took part in the 1914 actions at the Marne (5 to 10 September), the Aisne (12 September to 2 October) and the First Battle of Ypres (19 to17 November). On 26 December, 1914, II Corps was renamed Second Army.

Second Army also participated in the Second Battle of Ypres (22 April to 25 May 1915). Smith-Dorrien, wishing to make a strategic retirement from Ypres to cut casualties, fell foul again of French’s intentions for even more costly assaults. When he approached French in protest, he was immediately dismissed by means of a third party – Robertson (idem.) - with the famous words “Orace, you’re for ‘ome”.

Smith-Dorrien was offered a post in training, but this was scuttled by the Prime Minister, Asquith, who wanted to keep the position free for French, who he planned to sack from the command of the BEF! Smith-Dorrien was also offered the command in East Africa and accepted. But he fell ill en route and was unable to take up the post.

These shenanigans clearly illustrate the unbridled power that the well connected senior-most Great War generals could command over even senior army officers, leaving them with virtually no effective recourse to appeal when their careers were effectively ruined.

General comment: Smith-Dorrien’s most promising career on the Western Front was abruptly cut off by the animosity of the GOC, BEF, French; his memory (he died in a road accident in 1930) was tarnished by patent lies and deliberate falsehoods written in French’s memoir 1914. However, with the help of influential friends, a dignified Smith-Dorrien managed to get the official history of the First War (1922) to cite documents that supported his case.



Last Updated ( Tuesday, 14 October 2014 14:17 )  

Search with Google

Join the WFA

Join the WFA

Join the WFA online, by post, or at a Branch near you!

Site news

The WFA's site is undergoing a major rebuilding programme at the moment. We are moving to a new, faster server, with a new version of the content management system that has powered the site successfully since 2008. We will introduce a slightly different look and feel to that currently.
You may spot the phrase "Warning: Illegal string offset 'active' in .... " on parts of the website. Do not be alarmed! These are simply alerts but they do not constitute a danger to you or your computer. They are the result of a recent (current) server software upgrade that means there is a minor issue when listing are generated.
The website content (and, for the most part, its structure) will be unchanged and is indeed being expanded and improved. Search will be much more able to find the material you want in a site of almost 4,000 articles, and we will make other improvements such as content tagging.
We hope the work will be complete by around the end of October 2014.

Join us on Facebook

Support the WFA

If you have found this website to be of help to you, please support us.

donate_WFA

wfa-worldpay

Sponsored Links