Comparing the Somme 1916 and Arras 1917

Speaker: Mike Coyle
Large 000000 2026 11 17T231039.356

Both battles were equally fierce, both with heavy losses, yet a century on, it is the Somme that lives in our consciousness, while relatively few know of the Battle of Arras. This talk asks why.   

Mike Coyle is an experienced presenter, researcher and occasional writer on military history. His interest in this comparison was sparked by discovering the death of a great-uncle at Arras in May 1917. He was concerned that few know of the greater Battle of Arras whilst all know of ‘The Somme’. 

His research caused him to investigate and compare the two battles in terms of Leadership, Firepower, Logistics, Casualties, the way the battles were reported, and how they were received at home. The results formed the basis of a BA (Hons) dissertation.

This talk looks at that research and attempts to draw conclusions.    

Battle Of Arras 1917
Men of the Machine Gun Corps (MGC) during the Battle of Arras. IWM (Q 5172)
Event organiser: Scotland (South) branch
21 March 2027 14:00 to 21 March 2027 16:30
The Scots Guards Club, 2 Clifton Terrace, Haymarket, Edinburgh, EH12 5DR
Branch contacts
Ken Nisbet
(Branch Chairman)
Email Ken Nisbet

Other upcoming events for Scotland (South) branch

HW
6 December 2026

Lieutenant General Sir Aylmer Hunter-Weston: 'A slashing man of action' at the Somme.

Read more