Remembered
On This Day, 6 November 1914

Carl Hans Lody was shot as a spy on this day in 1914

Carl Hans Lody
Carl Hans Lody

Lody walked steadily, stiffly upright, and yet as easily and unconcernedly as though he was going to a tea-party, instead of to his death. His eyes were upturned to the gloomy skies, and his nostrils eagerly drank in the precious air that was soon to be denied them. But his face was quite calm and composed – almost expressionless.

How did a German Naval officer end up in the medieval Tower of London and about to be executed on this day in 1914?

Carl Hans Lody was born in Berlin on 20 January 1877. Following the death of both of his parents before he was eight, he entered an orphanage and later became an apprentice in a shop in Halle. In 1893, aged 16, he joined a sailing ship as a cabin boy and later studied at the German maritime academy, before joining the Imperial German Navy. Lody later went onto the naval reserve and obtained a captain's licence on merchant ships.

Carl Lody In Naval Uniform
Lody in Naval Uniform

Following a serious illness he was unable to carry on with his career and, instead found employment as a guide with the Hamburg American Line. Following an unsuccessful marriage in America, Lody returned to Germany in early 1914 with a large sum from his former wife's rich parents as 'compensation'. Shortly after this he was recruited by German Naval Intelligence and - when war broke out - it was decided he should go to Scotland to monitor movements of Royal Navy ships in the Firth of Forth.

To help him, German Naval Intelligence had acquired an American passport in the name of Charles Inglis, which tied in with his American-accented English.

Carl Lody's Passport
Lody's American passport in the name of "Charles A. Inglis"

One of his handlers thought his chances of success were "practically nil" - he was despatched without even learning how to send messages in code. Posing as an American tourist, Lody travelled via Norway and arrived in Newcastle in late August 1914. He immediately moved on to Edinburgh, from where he sent a telegram to an address in Stockholm which was known by MO5(g) [later MI5] to be that of a German agent.

As the British Secret Service was now alerted to 'Charles Inglis' being a spy, Lody's mission was compromised before it had even started. Moving to a boarding house, Lody (as Inglis) sent a letter to the same Stockholm address. Within the envelope was a second envelope which contained a letter passing on totally inaccurate information about the transportation of masses of Russian troops through Britain destined to the Western Front. Obviously Lody was simply passing on rumours rather than accurate material. For this reason the letter (which had been opened and read by MO5(g)) was allowed to go on its way.

Carl Lody's Letter
Lody's letter of 4 September 1914, reporting as true the unfounded rumour that Russian troops had landed in Scotland and were travelling south by train

The letter read:

Will you kindly communicate with Berlin at once by wire (code or whatever system at your disposal) and inform them that on Sept. 3rd great masses of Russian soldiers have passed through Edinburgh on their way to London and France. Although it must be expected that Berlin has knowledge of these movements, which probably took its start at Archangel, it may be well to forward this information. It is estimated here that 60,000 men have passed, numbers which seem greatly exaggerated. I went to the depot [station] and noticed trains passing through at high speed, blinds down. The landing in Scotland took place at Aberdeen.

Yours very truly Charles.

His lack of training - using neither code or invisible inks - made the British Secret Service's job ridiculously easy. Further letters were intercepted and allowed to reach their destination in the hope that he would reveal details of other spies working in the UK. He spent a few days in London before returning to Edinburgh in mid September where he undertook further, ineffectual, espionage work.

Carl Lody Letter
Letter sent by Lody on 14 September 1914

The message reads:

"Enclosed cutting from the Edinburgh The News of the World. Typical for the English way of causing ill-feeling and at the same time characteristic of the perfect ignorance of journalists in this country regarding the difference between military weapons and military tools. But this does not make any difference - the people here believe everything. Yours truly, Nazi." [The name "Nazi" was a nickname for the male name Ignatz (Ignatius).]

Card Lody Envolope
Envelopes sent by Lody from Edinburgh, 26 September 1914. The first envelope was sent to a cover address in Sweden; the second envelope, which enclosed the letter, was concealed inside the first and was addressed to Lody's controllers in Berlin.

Fearing he was arousing the suspicions of his landlady, he decided to head to Dublin, again his letter was intercepted and - because (for once) it contained information of value - it was not forwarded.

Writing from Dublin, further letters were intercepted and - deemed again to be of value - were not allowed to continue to his handlers . By now the British decided that Lody should be arrested and the Royal Irish Constabulary was given instructions on the morning of 2 October - he was found in his hotel later that day. On his arrest, he was found to be carrying German gold, a note book with details of British ships and a receipt from a Berlin tailor in his real name.

Lody's trial (uniquely not held in secret) took place at the end of October at Middlesex Guildhall in Parliament Square (now the Supreme Court of the United Kingdom). During the proceedings a humorous incident occurred, reported by the Daily Express on 31 October 1914. Lody's landlady was asked if she could see Charles Inglis (ie Lody) in court:

"...she looked everywhere except at the dock. Lody, who was sitting, stood up and gently waved his hands to attract her attention, while he smiled broadly and almost broke into laughter at the absurdity of the situation."

When he came to give evidence, Lody said that he had been sent to the UK "to remain until the first [naval] encounter had taken place between the two Powers, and to send accurate information as regards the actual losses of the British Fleet".

Lody In Court
Carl Hans Lody in the dock during his trial

Not surprisingly, Lody was found guilty and was sentenced to death (although he was not present in court when the sentence was announced). Some difficulty was experienced in selecting a place for his execution. He had been held in Wellington barracks under the guard of the 3rd Battalion Grenadier Guards. As only a short amount of time was available to select a place for his execution, the Tower of London was selected, even though it remained open to tourists (and would be open on the day of his execution). Lody's execution was to take place at the Tower's rifle range located in the eastern part of the Outer Ward between Martin and Constable Towers, behind the Outer Curtain wall and out of public sight.

Tower Of London In WW1
The Tower of London during WW1

Lody was informed of his impending execution on the evening of 5 November and was brought to the Tower in a police van. According to the Daily Express, he "received the news calmly and with no sign of surprise."

Whilst at the tower, he wrote two final letters. One of these was addressed to the CO of the 3/Grenadier Guards:

11859765 9Af7ad4a E77b 4514 A2f0 6B9d435b6913
Lody's letter to the Grenadier Guards CO.

The morning of 6 November 1914 dawned. It was cold and foggy. Lody was collected from his cell by the Assistant Provost-Marshal, Lord Athlumney. Lody asked, "I suppose that you will not care to shake hands with a German spy?", to which Lord Athlumney replied, "No. But I will shake hands with a brave man."

James Herbert Gustavus Meredyth Somerville, 2Nd Baron Athlumney, Assistant Provost Marshall Of London
James Herbert Gustavus Meredyth Somerville, 2nd Baron Athlumney, Assistant Provost Marshall of London

What happened next was later described by John Fraser, one of the Yeoman Warders:

Nobody liked this sort of thing. It was altogether too cold-blooded for an ordinary stomach (particularly that of a soldier, who hates cold-bloodedness) to face with equanimity, and it is not too much to say that, of that sad little procession, the calmest and most composed member was the condemned man himself.

For the Chaplain, in particular, it was a bad time. He had never had a similar experience, and his voice had a shake in it as he intoned the solemn words of the Burial Service over the living form of the man it most concerned . . .

The escort and the firing-party, too, were far from comfortable, and one could see that the slow march suitable to the occasion was getting badly on their nerves. They wanted to hurry over it, and get the beastly business finished.

But the prisoner walked steadily, stiffly upright, and yet as easily and unconcernedly as though he was going to a tea-party, instead of to his death. His eyes were upturned to the gloomy skies, and his nostrils eagerly drank in the precious air that was soon to be denied them. But his face was quite calm and composed – almost expressionless.

Lody was buried in an unmarked grave in the East London Cemetery in Plaistow, which also received the bodies of other spies to be executed later in the war. In 1924 the grave received a marker. The headstone was destroyed by a Luftwaffe bomb in the Second World War, and the present headstone was erected in 1974.

6 November 1914, broke cold, foggy and bleak, and at a very early hour Lody was brought from his cell, and the grim procession formed up on the veranda of the Tower Main Guard. It was led by the Chaplain, solemnly reading the Burial Service, followed by the prisoner, with an armed escort marching on either side of him, and the firing-party of eight stalwart guardsman bringing up the rear.

Nobody liked this sort of thing. It was altogether too cold-blooded for an ordinary stomach (particularly that of a soldier, who hates cold-bloodedness) to face with equanimity, and it is not too much to say that, of that sad little procession, the calmest and most composed member was the condemned man himself....

A few moments later the procession disappeared through the doorway of the sinister shed, and shortly after that came the muffled sound of a single volley. Carl Lody had paid!

John Fraser, Yeoman Warder, 1914

Lody's Grave
Lody's grave

Also remembered in November

1 November 1914

George Edward Randall was killed in action on this day in 1914

Read more about George Edward Randall
2 November 1917

Joseph James Schultz was killed in action on this day in 1917

Read more about Joseph James Schultz
3 November 1914

Joshua Crossley died of illness on this day in 1914

Read more about Joshua Crossley
4 November 1915

Philip Anthony Brown died of wounds on this day in 1915

Read more about Philip Anthony Brown
5 November 1916

Charles Wilton Illingworth was killed in action on this day in 1916

Read more about Charles Illingworth
7 November 1914

Joseph Claudius Descotes was killed in action on this day in 1914

Read more about Joseph Descotes
8 November 1914

Martin Brennan was killed in action on this day in 1914

Read more about Martin Brennan
9 November 1917

John Wood was killed in action on this day in 1917

Read more about John Wood
10 November 1914

Henry Bligh Fortesque Parnell was killed on this day in 1914

Read more about Henry Parnell
11 November 1918

George Ellison was killed in action on this day in 1918

Read more about George Ellison
12 November 1914

Francis Pepys was killed in action on this day in 1914

Read more about Francis Pepys
13 November 1916

Robert James Smith was killed in action on this day in 1916

Read more about Robert James Smith
14 November 1916

Arthur Henry Sharples was killed in action on this day in 1916

Read more about Arthur Sharples
15 November 1917

Oswald Chambers died of illness on this day in 1917

Read more about Rev Oswald Chambers
16 November 1916

Theodore Ionides died of wounds on this day in 1916

Read more about Theodore Ionides
17 November 1919

Roland MacGray was killed on this day in 1919

Read more about Roland MacGray
18 November 1917

Harry George Myers was killed in action on this day in 1917

Read more about Harry Myers
19 November 1915

George Harvey Mills was killed in action on this day in 1915

Read more about George Harvey Mills
20 November 1917

Stephen Carroll was killed in action on this day in 1917

Read more about Stephen Carroll
21 November 1917

George Wilson was killed in action on this day in 1917

Read more about George Wilson
22 November 1917

Alexander McNab was killed in action on this day in 1917

Read more about Alexander McNab
23 November 1917

Joseph Hoole died of wounds on this day in 1917

Read more about Joseph Hoole
24 November 1914

William Stewart Burdett Blackett died of wounds on this day in 1914

Read more about William Stewart Burdett Blackett
25 November 1916

Thomas Dawson was killed in action on this day in 1916

Read more about Thomas Dawson
26 November 1917

Herbert Walter Sawyer was killed in action on this day in 1917

Read more about Herbert Walter Sawyer
27 November 1916

Joshua Mitchell died of wounds on this day in 1916

Read more about Joshua Mitchell
28 November 1917

James Metcalfe died of wounds on this day in 1917

Read more about James Metcalfe
29 November 1917

Hugh Maxwell Hutchison died of wounds on this day in 1917

Read more about Hugh Hutchison
30 November 1917

William Dewhurst was killed in action on this day in 1917

Read more about William Dewhurst