Shaking General Monash’s Pedestal: the Battle of Hamel 4 July 1918

Published on 15 September 2025
Submitted by Dr Derek Clayton

The Battle of Hamel on 4 July 1918 is often heralded as the 'perfect battle', with all objectives taken, as planned, by the Australians in 93 minutes. It was indeed an undoubted success in the end, but both the planning and the execution were far from perfect.

General Monash's claim that the battle was 'free from any kind of hitch' needs closer examination, which is done in a detailed manner in this superb presentation by Derek Clayton.

Shaking General Monash’s Pedestal: the Battle of Hamel 4 July 1918
Key benefits of membership

Becoming a member of The Western Front Association (WFA) offers a wealth of resources and opportunities for those passionate about the history of the First World War. Here's just three of the benefits we offer:

Online Webinar Icon
Online webinars

The WFA regularly makes available webinars which can be viewed 'live' from home. These feature expert speakers talking about a particular aspect of the Great War.

Iwasthere Icon
I Was There!

Featured on The WFA's YouTube channel are modern day re-interpretations of the inter-war magazine 'I Was There!' which recount the memories of soldiers who 'were there'.

Pensionrecords Icon
Pension records

Explore over 8 million digitized pension records, Medal Index Cards and Ministry of Pension Documents, preserved by the WFA.

Other Articles

Walworth(Early20thc)Road Old2,Jpg
21 July 2026

The South London Ghost Stations: Why Five ‘Temporary’ WWI Closures Became Permanent

Read more
Gemini Generated Image 879Xur879xur879x
16 July 2026

The Battle of Verdun

Read more
110 Cover
12 July 2026

‘Somme 110’: the WFA marks 110 years since the first day

Read more
90308543 Ypres1.Edit
7 July 2026

One of Haig’s omissions? 38th (Welsh) Division at Mametz Wood, July 1916

Read more
Alternative With Lots Of Space For Text (1)
4 July 2026

Exploring the estate: meanings of the architecture and horticulture of the IWGC

Read more