Hiring and Firing on the Western Front

Published on 7 April 2011
Submitted by Prof John Bourne

In this talk, Dr John Bourne looks at how generals were selected and sacked during the WW1. This is a fascinating insight into how the British Army operated during this conflict and will burst many misapprehensions about so called 'donkeys'.

On the Western Front during World War I, the hiring and firing of generals was a complex process influenced by battlefield performance, political considerations, and the overall strategy of the war. While some commanders were initially successful, others faced dismissal or reassignment due to perceived failures, while some gained prominence through strategic thinking or political manoeuvring.

In some cases, political considerations played a role in promotions and demotions. For example, General Gough's removal after the Fifth Army's retreat was partly due to the need to find a scapegoat for the disaster, even though his actions were not solely responsible. 

John Bourne is a Vice President of The Western Front Association. This talk was recorded at the WFA Lancashire and Cheshire Branch of the WFA on 14 January 2011.

Hiring and Firing on the Western Front
Key benefits of membership

Becoming a member of The Western Front Association (WFA) offers a wealth of resources and opportunities for those passionate about the history of the First World War. Here's just three of the benefits we offer:

Bulletin Magazine Icon
Bulletin Magazine

This magazine provides updates on WW1 related news, WFA activities and events.

Virtual Battlefield Tours Icon
Virtual battlefield tours

Access online tours of significant WWI sites, providing immense learning experience.

Podcasts Ebinars Icon
Podcasts

Listen to over 300 episodes of the "Mentioned in Dispatches" podcast.

Other Articles

Gemini Generated Image 879Xur879xur879x
16 July 2026

The Battle of Verdun

Read more
110 Cover
12 July 2026

‘Somme 110’: the WFA marks 110 years since the first day

Read more
90308543 Ypres1.Edit
7 July 2026

One of Haig’s omissions? 38th (Welsh) Division at Mametz Wood, July 1916

Read more
Alternative With Lots Of Space For Text (1)
4 July 2026

Exploring the estate: meanings of the architecture and horticulture of the IWGC

Read more
Smith Thumb
27 June 2026

Identifying William Smith M.M. – a 25 year search

Read more