Douglas Haig - The 'Accidental Victor' of WW1?

Published on 13 January 2013
Submitted by Prof Gary Sheffield

The idea of Douglas Haig as an "accidental victor" in World War I is a complex one, debated by historians. While he led the British forces to victory in 1918, particularly during the "Hundred Days Offensive," his earlier leadership, particularly at the Somme and Passchendaele, is heavily criticized for high casualties.

Some argue that his later successes were a result of improved tactics and a unified Allied command, rather than a predetermined plan.

This lecture was given by WFA Vice President Professor Gary Sheffield at the WFA's 2010 AGM

Douglas Haig - The 'Accidental Victor' of WW1?
Key benefits of membership

Becoming a member of The Western Front Association (WFA) offers a wealth of resources and opportunities for those passionate about the history of the First World War. Here's just three of the benefits we offer:

Bulletin Magazine Icon
Bulletin Magazine

This magazine provides updates on WW1 related news, WFA activities and events.

Virtual Battlefield Tours Icon
Virtual battlefield tours

Access online tours of significant WWI sites, providing immense learning experience.

Podcasts Ebinars Icon
Podcasts

Listen to over 300 episodes of the "Mentioned in Dispatches" podcast.

Other Articles

Gemini Generated Image Nizgwnnizgwnnizg
28 April 2026

Alexander Kazakov – Russia’s greatest fighter ace of the First World War

Read more
64852F7b Ad22 46B4 9276 40121F4ec3f2
21 April 2026

The Lonely Anzac

Read more
Aa1jrmgl (1)
15 April 2026

Morale and Sensemaking on the Western Front

Read more
Gemini Generated Image 9Os6yp9os6yp9os6
9 April 2026

Ace in a Day: instances of WW1 airmen shooting down multiple opponents in a single day

Read more
George V Inspecting 29Th Division At Dunchurch March 1915 (1) (1)
6 April 2026

A Campaign in Two Halves: The 29th Division’s ‘Incomparables’ Sept 1915 - Jan 1916

Read more