The Centre Cannot Hold: Arras 1918 & the Failure of German Counterattack Doctrine

Published on 3 February 2021
Submitted by Dr Bill Stewart

In this presentation, which was delivered 'live' to an online audience Dr Bill Stewart, talks about the German defensive doctrine in 1917-1918.

The centrepiece of this doctrine was that of the counterattack allied with a flexible defence-in-depth to frustrate Allied attacks. The Germans could deliver punishing counter blows that violently overthrew Allied advances.

This presentation examines four case studies of German multi-battalion counterattacks in 1917 and 1918 at Arras based on Canadian and German records. The presentation will explain why, despite favourable circumstances, these counterattack in 1918 failed unlike 1917.

The Centre Cannot Hold: Arras 1918 & the Failure of German Counterattack Doctrine
Key benefits of membership

Becoming a member of The Western Front Association (WFA) offers a wealth of resources and opportunities for those passionate about the history of the First World War. Here's just three of the benefits we offer:

Bulletin Magazine Icon
Bulletin Magazine

This magazine provides updates on WW1 related news, WFA activities and events.

Virtual Battlefield Tours Icon
Virtual battlefield tours

Access online tours of significant WWI sites, providing immense learning experience.

Podcasts Ebinars Icon
Podcasts

Listen to over 300 episodes of the "Mentioned in Dispatches" podcast.

Other Articles

Jardin Ward 3
18 May 2026

The other nurses of Mudros – France’s Red Cross at Lemnos, 1915

Read more
Gemini Generated Image 7D9krb7d9krb7d9k
12 May 2026

Francesco Baracca: Italian WW1 air ace and the Ferrari connection

Read more
Invisible Foe (1) (1)
3 May 2026

The Invisible Foe: The 62nd Division in the Second Battle of the Marne 1918

Read more
Vol 1 Example Pages
2 May 2026

What happened to the ‘Bond of Sacrifice?’

Read more
Gemini Generated Image Nizgwnnizgwnnizg
28 April 2026

Alexander Kazakov – Russia’s greatest fighter ace of the First World War

Read more